A common objection against arguments for the existence of God asserts that such arguments, even if successful, fail to establish the truth of theism. This issue is discussed and critically analyzed, with a special focus on a presentation of the argument offered by the atheist philosopher Michael Martin. For book reviews, we look at 'God and Time: Four Views' and 'Resurrected? An Atheist and Theist Dialogue.' For the audience question we take another look at personal experiences and their relationship to our justification of religious belief.