LCIL International Law Seminar Series
48min2021 MAY 10
播放聲音
喜歡
評論
分享

詳細信息

Offshore exploitation of oil and gas started in the 1930s and thousands of installations are distributed around the world. Offshore installations threaten the environment, not only when it comes to oil spills, which are most visible but admittedly rare, but also in relation to their contribution to marine debris, pollution by dumping and greenhouse gas emissions. Nonetheless, the construction, operation and decommissioning of offshore installations, in the energy sector and beyond, is one of the maritime economic activities that has not yet been comprehensively regulated at the global level. The relevant international legal framework consists of a plethora of instruments adopted at the global, regional and supranational level, which have developed in different institutional settings and following different formats. The result is that, first, there is no specialised framework convention and consequently, the legal framework is fragmented at the sectoral, institutional, geographical and issue-related level. Second, the legal framework is weak because of the non-binding nature of many of the instruments that are the outcome of unconventional lawmaking1 processes. Third, the lawmaking processes in this field seem to be industry-led because of the important role the industry plays in unconventional lawmaking, both within and outside conventional fora.2 While unconventional lawmaking processes guarantee flexibility and the needed timeliness of regulatory efforts for a sector in continuous development and expansion, they do not necessarily allow for safeguarding or constructing the coherence of the legal framework. Moreover, the processes might be abused to push forward the agenda of the strongest actors, at the expense of global commons such as the marine environment and climate. In order to support these submissions, the present chapter will proceed in four steps. First, it will briefly introduce the existing conventional legal framework and highlight its fragmentation at the material and geographical levels. Special attention will be dedicated to the mechanisms for the further development of the law contained in the analysed instruments, e.g. rules of reference and monitoring mechanisms. Second, the analysis will concentrate on unconventional lawmaking performed by conventional actors, namely competent international organisations and treaty-bodies, with a focus on the standards for the conduct of environmental impact assessment. Third, the chapter will analyse the role of private actors, namely the industry, in unconventional lawmaking. Self-regulation plays an important role in the offshore energy sector. Codes of conducts adopted by multinational corporations, guidelines and recommendations drafted by professional associations highly influence the legal framework, also at the international level. A special mention will be made here to the renewable energy sector and the role of the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) as an example of an industry-led international organisation that has only produced unconventional law so far. Fourth, the legal nature of the outcomes of unconventional lawmaking will be analysed in light of their relationship to the existing conventional instruments. Specifically, it will be considered whether the unconventional lawmaking in the offshore energy sector has an autonomous normativity or whether their ‘being law’ derives from their interpretative function of applicable binding instruments. Some concluding remarks will be presented in order to highlight how unconventional lawmaking contributes to the fragmented and weak nature of the existing international legal framework. Seline Trevisanut (PhD, University of Milan; MA, Paris I-Panthéon Sorbonne) is Professor of International Law and Sustainability at Utrecht University since 2018. She joined Utrecht University in 2012 as Marie Skłodowsk...

查看更多

LCIL Friday Lecture: 'Judging ISIS Fighters Before Non-State Kurdish Courts in Syria: Is a Fair Trial Possible?'

47min

LCIL/CELS Webinar: Rapid Response Webinar on the War in Ukraine

1h 26min

LCIL Friday Lecture: 'How should we think about agility?: Regulatory agility and new landscapes of global regulatory governance' - Prof Andrew Lang, University of Edinburgh Law School

40min

LCIL Friday Lecture: 'CEDAW and transformative judicial obligations: the vulnerable migrant domestic worker and root causes of abuse' - Dr. Cheah W.L., National University of Singapore

27min

CUArb/LCIL Lecture Series: 'Third Party Funding: Looking at the Past and Projecting the Future'

1h 10min

The Eli Lauterpacht Lecture 2021: 'Global Governance for Health – why has it failed?' - Dame Sally Davies

1h 4min

CUArb/LCIL Lecture Series: 'Multiple courts and tribunals: forum competition, fragmentation or complementarily'

1h 8min

CUArb/LCIL Lecture Series: 'Soft Law and International Arbitration: an Interactive Q&A on the Key Instruments and Developments'

1h 4min